Skip to content
Back to articles

What New York’s DTC Brands Learned the Hard Way About Ad Platforms

New York has produced some of the best-known direct-to-consumer brands of the last fifteen years, from Warby Parker to Glossier. Many brands in the city grew up on the same playbook: find buyers through paid social and search ads, then scale the spend.

That playbook still works. But it leaves brands depending on platforms whose rules they don’t control.

Space’M, an eCommerce SEO agency with an office on Lexington Avenue in New York and another in Eindhoven, works with brands that want to change that balance. The agency’s founders also run their own online stores, selling across the United States and Europe, so they deal with the same platforms as their clients.

“New York brands are great at building demand,” says Bram Vermolen, CEO of Space’M Online. “The risk is that almost all of it reaches them through two or three ad platforms. When one of those changes the rules, the brand pays for it the next morning.”

When the platform changes, the brand pays

The clearest example came in 2021. Apple’s App Tracking Transparency update made it harder for apps to track users across other apps and websites. That hit the way many mobile ads target buyers and measure sales.

The effect was large enough that Meta told investors it expected the change to reduce its 2022 sales by about $10 billion. For brands that relied on those ads, the costs of finding new customers jumped, and nothing about their products or stores had changed.

Platform rules are only part of it. Click prices also keep climbing. WordStream’s 2026 benchmark puts the average Google Ads click at $5.42, more than double the $2.32 it was in 2016. And Gartner reports that marketing budgets have barely moved, at 7.8% of company revenue in 2026.

Search as the channel a brand builds itself

Organic search works differently. A store’s rankings come from its own pages: the categories, product pages and guides it publishes. There’s no bid to win each time and no ad account that can be paused.

Space’M is clear that SEO isn’t risk-free. Google updates its search systems regularly, and rankings can move.

“The difference is where the work lives,” says Vermolen. “If an ad platform changes its rules, the money you spent last year is gone. If Google updates its search results, the pages, the content and the links you built are still on your site, and you can improve them.”

What this looks like for a New York brand

For a brand selling from New York to the rest of the country, or abroad, a few checks show how exposed it is:

  • What share of new customers comes in through ads, and through which platforms.
  • Which high-intent searches in its category the brand doesn’t rank for yet.
  • Whether its category and product pages answer what shoppers search for, or only work as landing pages for ads.

Brands that ship beyond the US face the same questions in every new market. Each country has its own search behavior, and in Space’M’s experience, a store that ranks well in New York has to start over in Germany or the UK.

Not a case against ads

Space’M doesn’t tell brands to stop advertising. Ads are often the fastest way to test a product or launch in a new market.

“We run ads for our own stores too,” Vermolen says. “We just don’t want one platform’s policy update to decide whether we have a good quarter. Search gives a brand a base of customers that keeps coming in, whatever happens in the ad auctions.”